WESLEY CHAPEL’S NEIGHBORHOOD PIZZERIA · Dine-in · Pickup · Delivery
NYPIZZA Best NY Pizzaof Wesley Chapel Inc.
Order Online
Hand-tossed · Stone-fired · Made fresh

Real New York pizza, right here.

Thin, crisp, chewy and built to fold. Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel Inc. brings authentic New York-style pizza and neighborhood hospitality to Wesley Chapel every day.

Start an Order Explore the Menu
Fresh dough daily · Full pies and slices · Dine-in, pickup or delivery
↗Order Pickup or DeliveryUse our direct online ordering menu ☎Call (813) 994-2200Questions, catering and order help ⌖27429 Wesley Chapel BlvdGet turn-by-turn directions
The real slice

New York standards. Wesley Chapel home.

Great New York pizza starts long before the oven. Our dough is prepared fresh, given time to develop flavor, then hand-stretched and baked hot on stone for a crust that is crisp underneath, chewy inside and ready to fold.

We top every pie with bright tomato sauce, quality mozzarella and the ingredients your family actually wants to eat. No gimmicks—just the unmistakable balance that makes a New York slice a New York slice.

See How We Make It
Square Sicilian pizza with a crisp edge and airy crust
Fresh
DailyNever rushed
Start with a favorite

There’s a pie for every table

Build your own or choose a specialty. Our full menu also includes calzones, stromboli, wings, subs, Italian dinners, salads, desserts and more.

New York-style cheese pizza with a lifted slice

Classic NY Cheese

Bright sauce, melted mozzarella and the thin, foldable crust that defines the style.

Build your pizza →
Thick square Sicilian pizza

Sicilian & Grandma

Square pies with an airy interior, crisp base and deeply caramelized edges.

See square pies →
Pizza, wings, garlic knots, pasta and salad arranged for a group

Specialties & More

Loaded specialty pizzas plus wings, garlic knots, pasta, subs, salads and family favorites.

Explore the full menu →
Why it tastes right

Old-school methods make the difference

Pizza this simple leaves nowhere to hide. Every step matters.

01

Fresh Dough

Prepared and rested for flavor, texture and the right New York chew.

02

Hand Stretched

No presses. Skilled hands shape each pie while preserving the crust.

03

Stone Fired

High heat creates a crisp underside without losing the foldable center.

04

Quality Toppings

Balanced sauce, mozzarella and fresh ingredients in every bite.

Feeding a crowd?

Pizza, wings, salads, pasta trays and more for offices, teams, parties and family gatherings.

Plan Your CateringCall the Store
Proudly local

Serving Wesley Chapel and nearby neighborhoods

Stop in for a slice, take a family dinner home or order delivery where available. Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel Inc. serves our hometown and surrounding communities.

Wesley ChapelLutzLand O’ LakesNew TampaSeven OaksMeadow PointeWiregrassPebble CreekTampa Palms
Visit us

One location. Your neighborhood.

Address27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd
Wesley Chapel, FL 33544
HoursSun–Thu: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
Phone(813) 994-2200
Directions & Details
Order Online