WESLEY CHAPEL’S NEIGHBORHOOD PIZZERIA · Dine-in · Pickup · Delivery
Made for your appetite

Our menu

From a classic foldable cheese slice to fully loaded specialty pies, square Sicilian pizza and Italian comfort food, there is plenty to bring everyone to the table.

See Live Menu & Prices
Pizza first

Build it your way

Choose your size, crust and toppings in our live ordering menu. Availability and current pricing are always shown before checkout.

Sicilian Pizza

Square, thick and airy with extra sauce and mozzarella, baked for crisp edges and a hearty bite.

Grandma Sicilian

A square favorite with garlic pesto, light marinara, light mozzarella and fresh basil.

Specialty Pizzas

Meat, veggie, Margherita, white, four cheese, BBQ chicken, Buffalo chicken, Philly cheesesteak and more.

Half & Half

Customize each side of your pizza so everyone at the table gets exactly what they want.

Calzones, Rolls & Stromboli

Personal, medium and family sizes filled with cheese, meats, vegetables or your favorite combination.

Sicilian pizza showing its airy interior
Beyond pizza

A full Italian-American menu

Come for the pizza and stay for the rest. Whether you need a quick lunch, a family dinner or a little bit of everything, we have options for the whole table.

  • Wings, garlic knots, mozzarella sticks and appetizers
  • Fresh salads, including Caesar, Greek and antipasto
  • Hot subs, including meatball, chicken parm and Philly cheesesteak
  • Italian dinners, pasta, lasagna, ravioli and baked specialties
  • Kids’ choices, desserts, beverages and sides
Open the Live Menu

Know what you want?

Order directly for pickup or delivery from Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel Inc.

Order Online